Scientometric Evaluation of Science-Centric Orientation of the National Legislation

TitleScientometric Evaluation of Science-Centric Orientation of the National Legislation
Publication TypeJournal Article
Year of Publication2020
AuthorsBoublyk, SG, Bulkin, IO, Mekh, OA
Short TitleSci. innov.
SectionGeneral Problems of the Modern Research and Innovation Policy
Introduction. The ability to build a science-intensive economy in Ukraine depends on the implementation of strategic approaches to the formation and implementation of a unified government science and technology policy. One of the main conditions for the implementation of effective government policy is to amend, in terms of quality and quantity, the applicable laws and regulations with documents of scholarly research orientation.
Problem Statement. Actual task is to assess the scientse-centric orientation of legislative acts as a quantitative criterion of «knowledge intensity» of the national legislation.
Purpose. To obtain scientometric evaluation of science-centric orientation of the national legislative acts. 
Materials and Methods. The main methods of research are as follows: the scientometric (slang) method for the analysis of texts of legal acts and the statistical methods for structuring and comparative analysis of legislative acts as statistical units. 
Results. A survey of the statistical base of legislative acts of the supreme government bodies in 1992—2018 has revealed inconsistency in the managerial decisions of the top government authorities. In addition, there have been established periodic, stable statistical relationships between the intensity of scientific law-making and the expenditure on scholarly research and R&D activities. The original scientometric approaches to assessing the scientific orientation of the national legislation have been developed.
Conclusions. Within the period of independence, the main problems of public administration regarding science and technology sphere in Ukraine have been as follows: competition for executive powers between the Cabinet of Ministry and the Presidential Administration; the focus of the Cabinet of Ministers on the redistribution of expenditures on science; the absence of strategic (long-term) approaches to the formation and implementation of a single R&D policy at the government level. It is necessary to reform the system of legislation of Ukraine for the sake of its science-centric orientation, in particular, because of the urgent need to adapt it to the legislation of the European Union in the field of science, technology, and innovation.
Keywordsand index of science-centric orientation, legislation, R&D sphere, science, science-centric legislative acts
1. Legislation of Ukraine in the field of scientific, scientific and technical, and innovative activity: Collection legislation. acts: as of February 1 2013 (Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine, Commitee on Science and Education). (2013). L.M. Grinevich (ed.); order:  M.M. Shevchenko et al. Kiev: Parliamentary Publishing House [in Ukrainian].
2. State and legislative support for financing scientific and technical activities in Ukraine. hearing materials at the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine Committee on Science and Education March 13. 2013 (Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine, Committee on Science and Education). (2014). L.M. Grinevich (ed.); order:  M.M. Shevchenko et al. Kiev: Parliamentary Publishing House [in Ukrainian].
3. On the state and problems of financing education and science in Ukraine. Materials parlam. hearings in the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine on November 16. 2016 (Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine, Committee on Science and Education). (2017). O.V. Spivakovs’kyy (ed.); order: О. M. Levchuk et al. Kiev: Parliamentary Publishing House  [in Ukrainian].
4. Parliamentary hearing: «National innovation system: status and law enforcement development». Recommendations project. (2018). Ekonomist, 3(377), 19-25 [in Ukrainian].
5. Paton, B. Ye. (2015). On the activities of the National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine in 2009-2014, respectively, and the main task of the next period (report at the session of the General Meeting of NAS of Ukraine 15 April 2015). Visnyk NAN Ukraine, 5, 15–21 [in Ukrainian].
6. Pakhomova, A. O. (2011). General characteristics of the legislation used research. Visnyk of the Academy of Advocates of Ukraine, 2(21), 52–58 [in Ukrainian].
7. Popovych, O. S., Kapitsa, Yu. M. (2012). The legal field of science requires substantial improvement: before the amendments to the Law of Ukraine "On Scientific and Scientific and Technical Activities" are adopted. Science and Science of Science, 4(78), 32–39 [in Ukrainian].
8. Nahorichna, O. S., Konovalov, Yu. O. (2014). Legislative support for the process of state regulation of research activities. Public administration, improvement and development, 5.
URL: (Last accessed: 01.02.2019) [in Ukrainian].
9. Avigdor, G., Atamanova, Y., Bulkin, I., Butnik-Siversky, O., Galenko, I., Isakova, N., Shkvorets, Yu. (2011). The analysis of the legislation of Ukraine in the sphere of research, developments and innovation activity and suggestions for amendments for legislation. EU Project “Enhance Innovation Strategies, Policies and Regulation in Ukraine”. Kiyv: Fenix. 
10. Belevtsova, S. O. (2012). Current Problems of Modern National Legal Terminology Proceedings of Kharkiv National Pedagogical University GS Pans. "Right", 2012, Kharkiv, 144-149.
11. Mekh, O. A. (2014). Research Intensity of the National Security of Ukraine: Analysis of Legal Principles. Science and science of science, 3(85), 11–22 [in Ukrainian].
12. Boublyk, S. G. (2016). Scientific Approach to Analysis of Legal Acts in Science and Technology Field. Science and science of science, 2(92), 26–39 [in Russian].
13. Boublyk, S. G. (2017). Scientometric Study of the Legislation. Science and science of science, 4(98), 46–64 [in Ukrainian].
14. Nalimov, V. V., Mulchenko, Z. M. (1969). Scientometrics. Studying the development of science as an information process. Moscow: Nauka [in Russian].
15. Haitun, S. D. (1983). Scientometrics: Status and Prospects. Moscow: Nauka [in Russian].
16. Čech, R., Popescu, I.-I., Altmann, G. (2013). Methods of analysis of a thematic concentration of the text. Czech and Slovak Linguistic Review, 3, 4–21.
17. Čech, R., Garabík, R., Altmann, G. (2015). Testing the thematic concentration of text. Journal of Quantitative Linguistics, 22,  215–232.
18. Tkachuk, A. (2011). Legislative Technique: a Textbook. Kyiv: Legal Status ICC.
19. All Documents of database "Legislation of Ukraine". Awards and honorary titles [classification code 110 ...]. URL: (Last accessed: 25.02.2019).
20. All Documents of database "Legislation of Ukraine". 
URL: (Last accessed: 25.02.2019).
21. Reshota, V. V. (2017). Acts of Ukraine’s President as Sources of Administrative Law. Juridical scientific and electronic journal [Electronic journal], 5, 100–103 [in Ukrainian]. 
URL: (Last accessed: 20.02.2019).