1Kapitsa, Yu., 1Aralova, N
1Center of Intellectual Property and Technology Transfer, the National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine, Kyiv
Sci. innov. 2015, 11(2):51-68
https://doi.org/10.15407/scine11.02.051
Section: Legal Protection of Intellectual Property
Language: English
Abstract: 

The existing approaches used for setting the royalty rates for technology transfer agreements and based on the experience of research institutions of the National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine, research organizations and universities in Europe and USA have been reviewed. The existing rates have been analyzed; recommendations on setting the royalty rates for technology transfer agreements between research institutions and foreign and domestic partners have been elaborated.

Keywords: license agreement, licensee, licensor, royalty rates, technology transfer agreement
References: 

1. Podatkovyj kodeks Ukrainy. Vidomosti Verkhovnoi Rady Ukrainy, 2011, №13—14 [in Ukrainian].
2. Parr R. Royalty Rates for Licensing Intellectual Property. John Wiley & Sons, Inc., April 6, 2007, 240 p. [in English].
3. Razgaitis R.C. Valuation and Dealmaking of Technology-Based Intellectual Property. Principles, Methods and Tools: Wiley, 2009, pp. 81—125 [in English].
4. Royalty Rates for Technology. Published by Intellectual Property Research Associates, 2001, 187 p. [in English].
5. Azghal’dov H.H., Karpova N.N. Otsenka stoymosty yntellektual’noj sobstvennosty y nemateryal’nykh aktyvov. Moskva, Ynstytut professyonal’noj otsenky, 2006, [in Russian].
6. Kozyrev A.N., Makarov V.L. Otsenka stoymosty nemateryal’nykh aktyvov y yntellektual’noj sobstvennosty. Moskva: RYTs HSh VS RF, 2003, [in Russian].
7. Smith G.V. Valuation of Intellectual Property and Intangible Assets. New York: John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 2000 [in English].
8. Royalty Rates for Technology. Intellectual Property Research Associates (IPRA), 2000, [in English].
9. Lee W.M. Determining Reasonable Royalty. Les Nouvelles, September 1992, pp. 124—128 [in English].
10. Degnan S., Horton C. A survey of licensed royalties. Les Nouvelles, June 1997, pp. 91—96 [in English].
11. Friedenson Jay P. Reason to license and not to license technology and patents. Practicing Law Institute Patents, Copyrights, Trademarks, and Literary Property Course Handbook, January—February 1991 [in English].
12. Kapitsa Yu.M., Mal’chevs’kyj I.A., Fedchenko L.Yu., Aralova N.I. Rekomendatsii z otsinky vartosti intelek tual’noi vlasnosti. Kyiv: Lybid’, 2001, [in Ukrainian].
13. Landis M.S. Buy law, sell high: a practical guide on the pricing and presentation of patents and technical information. J. of Proprietary Rights, 1996, 10 p. [in English].
14. Puzynia N.Yu. Otsenka yntellektual’noj sobstvennosty y nemateryal’nykh aktyvov. SPb.: Pyter, 2005, [in Russian].
15. Goldscheider J., Jarosch J., Mulhern C. Use of the 25 Persent Rule in the Valuating IP. Les Nouvelles, December 2002, pp. 123—133 [in English].
16. Razgaitis R.C. Early — Stage Technologies: Valuation and Pricing. N-Y: John Wiley &Sons, Inc., 1999, [in English].
17. Tsybulev P.N., Denysiuk V.A. Otsenka yntellektual’noj sobstvennosty. Kyiv: UkrYNTEY, 2002, [in Russian].
18. Krajniev P.P. Intelektual’na ekonomika: upravlinnia promyslovoiu vlasnistiu. Kyiv: Vydavnychyj dim «In Yure», 2004, 448 p. [in Ukrainian].
19. Licensing Economics Review. New Jersey, AUS Consultants, from http://www.ausinc.com/publications.html [in English].
20. McGavock D., Haas D., Patin M. Factors Affecting Royalty Rates. Les Novelles, June 1992, p. 107 [in English].
21. Kiley T. IPH Newsbrief, April 1990, published in Licensing Economics Review, September 1990, p. 4 [in English].
22. Royalties on patents for health care inventions. Harold A. Meyer III, from Novelint, March 2001, from http://www.cptech.org/ip/health/royalties [in English].
23. Corey D.G., Kahn E. Biomedical Royalty Rates: Some Approaches, Genetic Engineering News, July-August 1991, p. 4 [in English].
24. Lita Nelsen. Paper for the Association of University Technology Managers (AUTM). Massachusetts Institute of Technology, 1989, [in English].
25. Fundamentals of intellectual property valuation. A Primer for Identifying and Determining Value. The American Bar Association, Chicago, 2005, [in English].
26. Postanova Kabinetu Ministriv Ukrainy «Pro zatverdzhennia minimal’nykh stavok nahorody avtoram tekhnolohij i osobam, iaki zdijsniuiut’ ikh transfer» vid 4 chervnia 2008, N 520 [in Ukrainian].
27. Zajtsev Yu.S. Popravka k standartnym stavkam roialty na razlychye urovnej rentabel’nosty produktsyy lytsenzyatov y proyzvodytelej v stranakh-ystochnykakh etykh stavok. Yntellektual’naia sobstvennost’. Promyshlennaia sobstvennost’, 2001, № 5, pp. 50—51 [in Russian].
28. Tsybul’ov P.M., Chebotar’ov V.P., Zinov V.H., Suini Yu. Upravlinnia intelektual’noiu vlasnistiu. Za red. P.M. Tsybul’ova. Kyiv: K.I.S., 2005, [in Ukrainian].
29. Novosel’tsev O. Otsenka yntellektual’noj sobstvennosty. Metody rascheta tseny lytsenzyy. 8-ia mezhdunarodnaia nauchno-praktycheskaia konferentsyia «Aktual’nye problemy yntellektual’noj sobstvennosty». Kyiv: UkrTsYPYP, 2004, pp. 92—110 [in Russian].
30. Royalty Rates for Pharmaceuticals & Biotechnology. 7th Edition. Published by IPRA, Inc., Yardley, Pennsylvania, 2010, 360 p. [in English].
31. Royalty Range. European Royalty Database, from http://www.royaltyrange.com [in English].
32. ktMINE database of License Agreements, Royalty & Market Rates, Patents & Assignments etc., from http://www.ktmine.com/company [in English].
33. Royalty Source, from http://www.royaltysource.com [in English].
34. Licensing Economics Review. New Jersey, AUS Consultants. U.S., from http://www.ausinc.com/publications.html [in English].
35. Royalty Rates for Technology. 4th Edition. Sample report. Published by Intellectual Property Research Associates, March 2010, 21 p., from http://gmsystems.com/uploads/3/1/4/3/3143302/royalty—rates—for—technology—4th—edition—sample—report.pdf [in English].